I recently went on a spiritual retreat in which most of the participants were Catholic. From the ages of 16-31, I belonged to evangelical Protestant churches (where there were hostile feelings toward Catholics). About a year ago, though, I slowly decided to shed this evangelical identity. And at this recent retreat, I realized that I am no longer Protestant. But I’m also not Catholic. I’m simply a Christ follower who has been deeply shaped by a lot of denominations/orders. I can be both Catholic and Protestant—and also neither of them. As Rachel Held Evans wrote, “I may not worship in an evangelical church anymore or even embrace evangelical theology, but as long as I have an investment in the church universal, I have an investment in the community that first introduced me to Jesus.” I have an investment in the church universal. Here are the churches that I am grateful for because of their mutual investment:
Pentecostal: The Rock and Bethel
As a sophomore in high school, I accepted Jesus within a Pentecostal church called The Rock. For the first time in my life, I heard the message that Christianity is not a religion but a loving relationship with Jesus. Though I was a little bit freaked out by behaviors like speaking in tongues and holy laughter, I learned about the boldness of the Holy Spirit through this denomination. I left The Rock because my mom was afraid that it was a cult, but I will be forever thankful for individuals like Shane and Nick who invited me to this church and answered my countless questions.
And after being hurt by the C&MA (see below), the Pentecostal church—through a Bethel home church in Malaysia—once again brought healing to my soul. I needed to hear congregant members spontaneously shouting, “SO GOOD!” I needed songs like “Take Courage.” I even needed to feel a bit uncomfortable and out of control while participating in the ‘beanbag hot seat’ prayer. I don’t agree with some of the doctrine of Bethel, but I appreciate how the Allens, Frohlichs, Pastor Bill, and Pastor Kris allowed me to rediscover the intimacy of Jesus’ love.
International Evangelical: The Christian & Missionary Alliance
Tallmadge Alliance Church, including Pastor John and the youth group, was the church that discipled me and taught me how to exegete Scripture. Their annual youth conference, Life, taught me about purity culture—but also about having a passion for other cultures. I felt called to overseas work while watching flags and missionaries dance to “He Reigns.” This calling dictated the next six years of my life: getting my bachelor’s and master’s degrees, visiting African nations, becoming a missionary candidate, working at Lombard Bible Church for two years, getting consecrated, and getting appointed to Guinea, West Africa. I was mentored by some amazing women: Joanna, Kim, Luisa, Esther, Carol. The LBC youth group and people will also always hold a special place in my heart.
But the C&MA also hurt me badly. In their complementarian beliefs, they treated me as less than because I am a woman. The ‘youth pastor’ position was changed to ‘youth director,’ and I was paid at the poverty line. ‘Ordination’ was changed to ‘consecration.’ A letter to the president about the poor treatment of women in ministry was left unanswered. And then the real hurt came: they shunned me because I decided that I didn’t want to do church planting in West Africa. Instead, I wanted to become a teacher at an international school, but this wasn’t considered “proselytizing” enough. So, I left the C&MA, but I ended up living in Asia for a total of five years. I will forever love other cultures, but I never want to be in full-time vocational ministry.*
Non-Denominational Protestant: Citizens
When I moved back to the States, I was in need of community. One of the villages from Citizens made me their friend: the Kents, the Crosses, the Olsons, the Kodurus, the Safrans. I truly enjoyed the preaching of Pastor James and Leah. I appreciated the church’s emphasis on social justice. Their tagline is “a church for all people.” I do think they are seeking equality, equity, and inclusion among all ethnicities and socioeconomic groups. A constructive criticism would be to continue becoming multigenerational and having more female leadership.
But one thing I’ve learned is that not saying something says something. It’s similar to the idea that being ‘not racist’ is not the same as ‘antiracism.’ Words and actions must show inclusivity. By not including sexuality in the ideology of “for all people,” it means that you’re not affirming of LGBTQ+ individuals. As long as you’re not hurting or judging someone, it’s okay to hold a different belief. This is just too important of a belief for me.
Fundamentalist: M.B.
For a while, I really held anger against you. You wounded me when you called me a heretic because I support Black Lives Matter. But then I began to realize that you live with integrity; your values truly do shape your actions. Though I most often disagree with your values and actions, I respect how strongly you hold to them. Though it was white savior-y and lacked child safety at times, I also appreciate how you started a program to mentor kids.*
Catholic: Roman Catholic and Jesuits
Catholics shaped my story before I was born. My dad was baptized Byzantine Orthodox (and I was, too), but he attended St. Patrick’s Church in Kent, which is Roman Catholic. They had a strict policy against divorce, so my dad adamantly stated, “then my family will have nothing to do with religion.” Thus, I didn’t have exposure to Christianity until I was a sophomore in high school.
Ignatian disciplines, like Lectio Divina, imaginative prayer, and the Examen, were introduced to me by Susan and Kirk in Malaysia. Then, they were re-emphasized by individuals like Brian and Martha. Once I started at Walsh Jesuit, I began practicing the Ignatian disciplines and ideals more. I value the emphasis on “men and women for others” and “A.M.D.G.” I’m also learning how liturgy connects the universal and generational Church.
I don’t necessarily like that Catholics also are not affirming of LGBTQ+ or women in ministry, and that ministers don’t let me take the Eucharist because I’m not Catholic, but I see the Ignatians heart for Jesus; this is helping me connect more to my emotions than my intellect.
Evolving Faith: The online quarantine “churches”
Quarantining was one of the best things for my faith. I truly had to let go of control and seek “the daily bread” as the beloved. Having a sabbath from the ritualistic routines of Sunday church brought rest; I was able to blog again, hikes bike, eat my Taco Tantos burrito, drink chai, invest in my family, and learn from HPST, The Knight C-Bus.
I was also able to find an online community of fellow heretics who love Jesus: Jen Hatmaker, Queerology, The Evolving Faith Podcast, First Congregational Church of Akron, Jen from Trotwood Church of the Brethern. You have given me the bravery to not be closeted in my beliefs and identity.
Thus, I’ve realized that I don’t miss church buildings, especially singing songs. But I do miss discussing my thoughts on the Bible with other people. So, I think I’m going to find one or two individuals who will have a weekly Bible study with me. I will continue to invest.
*December 30, 2021
Dear Reformed Theology,
After listening to The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill, I realized how much trauma I have from your harmful ideologies. During a pivotal time in my identity formation (16-24), you made me feel lesser because of my gender; you made me believe that I couldn’t preach and deserved to be paid near the poverty line. You made me feel like my worthiness was in seeking a husband and maintaining my purity—which led to a fear of sex (I literally have anxiety attacks when it comes to physical intimacy). You made me feel like a heretic because I began believing theology that was more inclusive. You made me feel shameful because I don’t identify according to your “normal” standards.
But I realize that you don’t deserve to dictate my emotions. You are not God; you are an institution that is filled with broken people, just like me. I don’t have to listen to you hurtful messages anymore.
And I also don’t have to lessen my faith because it doesn’t look like yours. I love Jesus, and you can’t steal that from me. I will continue to worship God, but I will never sit in your pews of hypocrisy and judgment, just to people please. Thank you for introducing me to my faith, but I’m going to keep on evolving because you don’t serve me well anymore.
So, I guess, I forgive you.
Goodbye,
EMG